ÂýÐÔÆ¤·ôÀ£Ññ ÏÂÔØ±¾ÎÄ

¶ÔÕÕ×é

¢òÐÍ

ÖÎÁÆ×é ¶ÔÕÕ×é

18 13 12

4 4 2

5 5 3

3 2 2

6 2 5

66.7% -2.448 0.014 84.6%

58.3% -1.439 0.150

Óɱí19¿É¼û£¬¾­·Ç²ÎÊýÖȺͼìÑ飬Á½×黼Õß²¡Àí¢ñÐÍÁÆÐ§Í³¼Æ·ÖÎöP£¼0.05£¬Æä²îÒìÓÐͳ¼ÆÑ§ÒâÒ壻Á½×黼Õß²¡Àí¢òÐÍͳ¼Æ·ÖÎöP£¾0.05£¬Æä²îÒìÎÞͳ¼ÆÑ§ÒâÒå¡£ 2.4ÖÎÁÆ×éÖÎÁÆÇ°ºóÖ¢×´ÌåÕ÷»ý·Ö±È½Ï

±í20ÖÎÁÆ×éÖÎÁÆÇ°ºóÖ¢×´ÌåÕ÷»ý·Ö±È½Ï£¨·Ö£©

¹Û²ìÏîÄ¿ À£ÑñÊýÄ¿ À£ÑñÃæ»ý À£ÑñÉî¶È ÐÂÉúÈâÑ¿×éÖ¯ ÐÂÉúÉÏÆ¤×éÖ¯ ÈâѿɫÔó À£Ññ±ßԵɫÔó À£ÑñÃæ´¥Í´ ŧҺ ·ôΠ»µËÀÎïÐÔÖÊ »µËÀÎïÁ¿ ×Ü»ý·Ö

ÖÎÁÆÇ° 1.40¡À0.675 2.40¡À1.133 2.17¡À1.085 2.97¡À0.669 3.00¡À0.743 2.73¡À0.640 3.03¡À0.809 2.77¡À0.679 2.80¡À0.610 2.67¡À0.922 2.67¡À0.758 4.13¡À1.479 32.70¡À5.955

ÖÎÁƺó 0.67¡À0.661 0.63¡À0.615 0.60¡À0.563 0.57¡À0.568 0.67¡À0.661 0.63¡À0.615 0.60¡À0.563 0.57¡À0.504 0.57¡À0.568 0.63¡À0.615 0.53¡À0.507 1.07¡À1.015 7.70¡À7.047

t 5.430 9.307 7.365 21.153 15.930 18.936 15.527 15.832 16.804 11.549 17.147 9.761 21.651

P £¼0.05 £¼0.05 £¼0.05 £¼0.05 £¼0.05 £¼0.05 £¼0.05 £¼0.05 £¼0.05 £¼0.05 £¼0.05 £¼0.05 £¼0.05

Óɱí20¿É¼û£¬¾­Åä¶ÔÉè¼ÆµÄÁ½Ñù±¾¾ùÊýt¼ìÑ飬ÖÎÁÆ×éÖÎÁƺóÆäÖ¢×´ÌåÕ÷½ÏÖÎÁÆÇ°ÓÐÏÔÖø¸ÄÉÆ£¨p£¼0.05£©£¬ÓÐÏÔÖøÐÔ²îÒ죬¾ßÓÐͳ¼ÆÑ§ÒâÒ壬˵Ã÷ÖÎÁÆ×éÔÚÓÃÒ©ºó£¬¶ÔÓÚÂýÐÔÆ¤·ôÀ£ÑñµÄÖÎÁƾßÓÐÏÔÖøÐ§¹û¡£ 2.5¶ÔÕÕ×éÖÎÁÆÇ°ºóÖ¢×´ÌåÕ÷»ý·Ö±È½Ï

±í21¶ÔÕÕ×éÖÎÁÆÇ°ºóÖ¢×´ÌåÕ÷»ý·Ö±È½Ï£¨·Ö£©

¹Û²ìÏîÄ¿ À£ÑñÊýÄ¿ À£ÑñÃæ»ý À£ÑñÉî¶È ÐÂÉúÈâÑ¿×éÖ¯ ÐÂÉúÉÏÆ¤×éÖ¯ ÈâѿɫÔó À£Ññ±ßԵɫÔó À£ÑñÃæ´¥Í´ ŧҺ ·ôΠ»µËÀÎïÐÔÖÊ »µËÀÎïÁ¿ ×Ü»ý·Ö

ÖÎÁÆÇ° 1.43¡À0.679 2.47¡À1.224 2.43¡À1.073 3.07¡À0.691 2.87¡À0.730 2.80¡À0.925 2.67¡À0.884 2.70¡À0.794 2.90¡À0.803 2.57¡À0.858 2.67¡À0.844 3.87¡À1.383 32.40¡À5.934

ÖÎÁƺó 1.17¡À0.847 1.57¡À1.278 1.37¡À1.129 1.93¡À1.202 1.37¡À1.033 1.13¡À0.973 1.33¡À1.155 1.27¡À1.048 1.20¡À1.031 1.07¡À0.980 1.20¡À0.761 1.67¡À1.295 16.20¡À10.704

t 3.247 4.955 4.455 6.378 9.542 10.326 7.616 7.802 8.562 8.146 11.789 7.131 10.186

P £¼0.05 £¼0.05 £¼0.05 £¼0.05 £¼0.05 £¼0.05 £¼0.05 £¼0.05 £¼0.05 £¼0.05 £¼0.05 £¼0.05 £¼0.05

Óɱí21¿É¼û£¬¾­Åä¶ÔÉè¼ÆµÄÁ½Ñù±¾¾ùÊýt¼ìÑ飬¶ÔÕÕ×éÖÎÁƺóÆäÖ¢×´ÌåÕ÷½ÏÖÎÁÆÇ°ÓÐÏÔÖø¸ÄÉÆ£¨p£¼0.05£©£¬ÓÐÏÔÖøÐÔ²îÒ죬¾ßÓÐͳ¼ÆÑ§ÒâÒ壬˵Ã÷³£¹æÇå´´»»Ò©×éÔÚÓÃÒ©ºó£¬¶ÔÓÚÂýÐÔÆ¤·ôÀ£ÑñµÄÖÎÁƾßÓÐÒ»¶¨µÄÖÎÁÆÐ§¹û¡£ 1.6Á½×éÖÎÁƺóÖ¢×´ÌåÕ÷»ý·Ö±È½Ï

±í22Á½×黼ÕßÖÎÁƺóÖ¢×´ÌåÕ÷»ý·ÖÇé¿ö£¨·Ö£©

¹Û²ìÏîÄ¿ À£ÑñÊýÄ¿ À£ÑñÃæ»ý À£ÑñÉî¶È ÐÂÉúÈâÑ¿×éÖ¯

ÖÎÁÆ×é 0.67¡À0.661 0.63¡À0.615 0.60¡À0.563 0.57¡À0.568

¶ÔÕÕ×é 1.17¡À0.847 1.57¡À1.278 1.37¡À1.129 1.93¡À1.202

t -2.499 -3.604 -3.328 -5.632

p 0.015 0.001 0.002 0.000

ÐÂÉúÉÏÆ¤×éÖ¯ ÈâѿɫÔó À£Ññ±ßԵɫÔó À£ÑñÃæ´¥Í´ ŧҺ ·ôΠ»µËÀÎïÐÔÖÊ »µËÀÎïÁ¿ ×Ü»ý·Ö

0.67¡À0.661 0.63¡À0.615 0.60¡À0.563 0.57¡À0.504 0.57¡À0.568 0.63¡À0.615 0.53¡À0.507 1.07¡À1.015 7.70¡À7.047

1.37¡À1.033 1.13¡À0.973 1.33¡À1.155 1.27¡À1.048 1.20¡À1.031 1.07¡À0.980 1.20¡À0.761 1.77¡À1.431 16.20¡À10.704

-3.126 -2.379 -3.126 -3.296 -2.948 -2.051 -3.992 -2.186 -3.633

0.003 0.021 0.003 0.002 0.005 0.045 0.000 0.033 0.001

Óɱí22Ëùʾ£¬¾­³É×éÉè¼ÆµÄÁ½Ñù±¾¾ùÊýt¼ìÑ飬ÖÎÁÆ×éÓë¶ÔÕÕ×éÖÎÁƺó¸÷ÏîÖ¢×´ÌåÕ÷»ý·Ö¼°×Ü»ý·ÖÓÐÏÔÖø²îÒìÐÔ£¨P£¼0.05£©¡£±íÃ÷»ØÒ©ÔúÀïū˼¸à½Ï³£¹æÇå´´»»Ò©ÖÎÁÆÐ§¹û¸ü¼ÓÏÔÖø¡£

1.7Á½×黼ÕßÖÎÁÆÇ°ºóƤ·ôÀ£Ññƽ¾ùÃæ»ýÇé¿ö 1.7.1Á½×黼ÕßÖÎÁÆÇ°ºóƤ·ôÀ£Ññƽ¾ùÃæ»ýÇé¿ö

±í23Á½×黼ÕßÖÎÁÆÇ°ºóƤ·ôÀ£Ññƽ¾ùÃæ»ý£¨n£¬cm2£©

×é±ð ÖÎÁÆ×é

¶ÔÕÕ×é

ʱÆÚ ÖÎÁÆÇ° ÖÎÁƺó ÖÎÁÆÇ° ÖÎÁƺó

n 30 30 30 30

ƽ¾ùÃæ»ý 20.883Ê¿15.7741 2.6667Ê¿4.18193 22.067Ê¿15.7785 12.75Ê¿14.56658

Z -4.391 -3.308

P 0.000 0.001

Óɱí23¿É¼û£¬¾­·Ç²ÎÊýÖȺͼìÑé,Á½×黼ÕßÖÎÁÆÇ°ºóƤ·ôÀ£Ññƽ¾ùÃæ»ýÓÐÏÔÖøÐÔ²îÒ죨p£¼0.05£©£¬¾ßÓÐͳ¼ÆÑ§ÒâÒå¡£

1.7.2Á½×黼ÕßÖÎÁÆºóÆ¤·ôÀ£Ññƽ¾ùÃæ»ýÇé¿ö

±í24Á½×黼ÕßÖÎÁÆºóÆ¤·ôÀ£Ññƽ¾ùÃæ»ý£¨n£¬cm2£©

×é±ð

n

ƽ¾ùÃæ»ý

Z

P

ÖÎÁÆ×é ¶ÔÕÕ×é ºÏ¼Æ

30 30 60

2.6667ʿ4.18193 12.7500ʿ14.56658

-3.429

0.001

Óɱí24¿É¼û£¬¾­Á½¶ÀÁ¢Ñù±¾·Ç²ÎÊýÖȺͼìÑé,Á½×黼ÕßÖÎÁÆºóÆ¤·ôÀ£Ññƽ¾ùÃæ»ýÓÐÏÔÖøÐÔ²îÒ죨p£¼0.05£©£¬¾ßÓÐͳ¼ÆÑ§ÒâÒå¡£±íÃ÷»ØÒ©ÔúÀïū˼¸àÔÚËõСƤ·ôÀ£ÑñÃæ»ý·½Ãæ½Ï³£¹æÇå´´»»Ò©ÖÎÁÆÐ§¹û¸ü¼ÓÏÔÖø¡£

1.8Á½×黼ÕßÀ£ÑñÃæÑÕÉ«¸Ä±äʱ¼ä¡¢¸¯Èâ¾»»¯Ê±¼ä¡¢Éú¼¡Ê±¼ä±È½Ï 1.8.1Á½×黼ÕßÀ£ÑñÃæÑÕÉ«¸Ä±äʱ¼ä±È½Ï

±í25Á½×黼ÕßÀ£ÑñÃæÑÕÉ«¸Ä±äʱ¼ä±È½Ï£¨n£¬Ì죩

×é±ð ÖÎÁÆ×é ¶ÔÕÕ×é ºÏ¼Æ

n 30 30 60

ÑÕÉ«¸Ä±äʱ¼ä 7.40¡À2.238 13.33¡À2.249

t

-10.244

p

0.000

Óɱí25¿É¼û£¬¾­³É×éÉè¼ÆµÄÁ½Ñù±¾¾ùÊýt¼ìÑé,Á½×黼ÕßÀ£ÑñÃæÑÕÉ«¸Ä±äʱ¼äÓÐÏÔÖøÐÔ²îÒ죨p£¼0.05£©£¬¾ßÓÐͳ¼ÆÑ§ÒâÒå¡£±íÃ÷»ØÒ©ÔúÀïū˼¸à½Ï³£¹æÇå´´»»Ò©¸ÄÉÆÀ£ÑñÃæÑÕÉ«¿ì£¬Ð§¹ûÏÔÖø¡£

1.8.2Á½×黼ÕßÀ£ÑñÃæ¸¯Èâ¾»»¯Ê±¼ä±È½Ï

±í26Á½×黼ÕßÀ£ÑñÃæ¸¯Èâ¾»»¯Ê±¼ä±È½Ï£¨n£¬Ì죩

×é±ð ÖÎÁÆ×é ¶ÔÕÕ×é ºÏ¼Æ

n 30 26 56

¸¯Èâ¾»»¯Ê±¼ä 11.67¡À2.106 17.23¡À1.883

t

-10.352

0.000 P

Óɱí26¿É¼û£¬¾­³É×éÉè¼ÆµÄÁ½Ñù±¾¾ùÊýt¼ìÑé,Á½×黼ÕßÀ£ÑñÃæ¸¯Èâ¾»»¯Ê±¼äÓÐÏÔÖøÐÔ²îÒ죨p£¼0.05£©£¬¾ßÓÐͳ¼ÆÑ§ÒâÒå¡£±íÃ÷»ØÒ©ÔúÀïū˼¸à½Ï³£¹æÇå´´»»Ò©Ã÷ÏÔËõ¶Ì